第 01 集：The Tiny Rocket（小小火箭大挑戰）

{
  "id": "p01_watch_out_chatartpro_agent_retry_v3",
  "phrase_id": "p01",
  "phrase": "Watch out!",
  "provider": "ChatArtPro",
  "model": "Seedance 2.0 Fast",
  "submitted_at": "2026-05-22 10:49 CST",
  "diamonds_spent": 31,
  "source_url": "https://files.chatartpro.com/web-video/20260522/6a0fc4b9183e3.mp4",
  "file": "source_clips/p01_watch_out/p01_watch_out_chatartpro_agent_retry_v3.mp4",
  "status": "approved_with_required_intro_trim",
  "visual_qa": "pass: two characters, girl points down, boy nearly steps on floor rocket object",
  "audio_stt": "Watch out!",
  "required_audio": "Watch out!",
  "assembly_note": "Raw ChatArtPro clip starts with uploaded reference/first-frame hold; trim or mask first ~0.8s and use controlled phrase audio in final assembly if needed."
}

{
  "id": "p02_hold_on_black_soot_v1",
  "phrase_id": "p02",
  "phrase": "Hold on.",
  "provider": "ChatArtPro",
  "model": "Seedance 2.0 Fast",
  "submitted_at": "2026-05-22 15:34 CST",
  "diamonds_spent": 31,
  "source_url": "https://files.chatartpro.com/web-video/20260522/6a0ffe687d3b7.mp4",
  "file": "source_clips/p02_hold_on/p02_hold_on_black_soot_v1.mp4",
  "status": "rejected_visual_semantics",
  "visual_qa": "partial/fail: red button/rocket/STOP present, but no black smoke or soot-blackened faces",
  "audio_stt": "not used; visual rejected",
  "required_audio": "Hold on."
}

{
  "id": "p02_hold_on_black_soot_v2",
  "phrase_id": "p02",
  "phrase": "Hold on.",
  "provider": "ChatArtPro",
  "model": "Seedance 2.0 Fast",
  "submitted_at": "2026-05-22 15:39 CST",
  "diamonds_spent": 31,
  "source_url": "https://files.chatartpro.com/web-video/20260522/6a1007a7c789a.mp4",
  "file": "source_clips/p02_hold_on/p02_hold_on_black_soot_v2.mp4",
  "status": "candidate_visual_partial_audio_failed",
  "visual_qa": "partial: black soot faces and smoke visible; STOP gesture at end; red button visible; rocket disappears after explosion; acceptable as direction preview but not full source approval",
  "audio_stt": "Hahaha! Hold on!",
  "required_audio": "Hold on.",
  "failure_reason": "extra spoken laughter before target phrase; raw provider audio fails STT/content QA"
}

{
  "id": "p02_hold_on_seedance2_timing_v3",
  "phrase_id": "p02",
  "phrase": "Hold on.",
  "provider": "ChatArtPro",
  "model": "Seedance 2.0",
  "submitted_at": "2026-05-22 16:11 CST",
  "diamonds_spent": 55,
  "source_url": "https://files.chatartpro.com/web-video/20260522/6a1008b4d60a5.mp4",
  "file": "source_clips/p02_hold_on/p02_hold_on_seedance2_timing_v3.mp4",
  "status": "candidate_audio_timing_pass_visual_partial",
  "visual_qa": "partial: before-press setup has boy finger near red button and rocket visible, but STOP gesture weak; aftermath has soot-blackened faces and red button, rocket disappears after explosion.",
  "audio_stt": "Hold on",
  "audio_word_timing": "Hold 0.00-0.54; on 0.54-0.82",
  "required_audio": "Hold on before button press",
  "qa_summary": "Audio timing fixed and no extra speech; visual still partial due to weak early STOP gesture and missing rocket in aftermath."
}

{
  "id": "p02_hold_on_fast_topbutton_stophand_v4",
  "phrase_id": "p02",
  "phrase": "Hold on.",
  "provider": "ChatArtPro",
  "model": "Seedance 2.0 Fast",
  "submitted_at": "2026-05-22 16:17 CST",
  "diamonds_spent": 31,
  "source_url": "https://files.chatartpro.com/web-video/20260522/6a10106aa5b05.mp4",
  "file": "source_clips/p02_hold_on/p02_hold_on_fast_topbutton_stophand_v4.mp4",
  "status": "candidate_stt_pass_awaiting_human_visual_review",
  "visual_qa": "automated vision unavailable due usage limit; human review needed for top-mounted button and stop-hand timing",
  "audio_stt": "Hold on!",
  "audio_word_timing": "Hold 0.00-1.58; on 1.58-1.90",
  "required_audio": "Hold on before button press",
  "qa_frames": "qa/p02_hold_on_fast_topbutton_stophand_v4_contact_sheet.jpg",
  "qa_summary": "Fast model restored per user. Prompt forces button on top horizontal surface and STOP hand raised while speaking. STT has only Hold on, no extra words; visual needs human confirmation because vision QA quota hit 429."
}

{
  "id": "p03_my_turn_chatartpro_fast_v1",
  "phrase_id": "p03",
  "phrase": "My turn.",
  "provider": "ChatArtPro",
  "model": "Seedance 2.0 Fast",
  "submitted_at": "2026-05-24 09:13 CST",
  "diamonds_spent": 31,
  "source_url": "not captured; downloaded from visible latest result card",
  "file": "source_clips/p03_my_turn/p03_my_turn_chatartpro_fast_v1.mp4",
  "status": "candidate_visual_usable_audio_pass_needs_minor_review",
  "visual_qa": "usable but needs minor review: style/scene/turn-taking pass; 0.3s ghosting; tool slightly too real/pointed; Leo action could be stronger.",
  "audio_stt": "My turn!",
  "audio_word_timing": "My 3.86-4.50; turn 4.50-4.82",
  "required_audio": "My turn.",
  "qa_frames": "qa/p03_my_turn_contact_sheet.jpg"
}

{
  "id": "p04_no_way_worker_v1",
  "phrase_id": "p04",
  "phrase": "No way!",
  "provider": "ChatArtPro",
  "model": "Seedance 2.0 Fast",
  "submitted_at": "2026-05-24 11:56 CST",
  "diamonds_spent": 31,
  "source_url": "https://files.chatartpro.com/web-video/20260524/6a12515837f66.mp4",
  "file": "source_clips/p04_no_way/p04_no_way_chatartpro_worker_v1.mp4",
  "status": "rejected_visual_audio_failed",
  "audio_stt": "My turn!",
  "required_audio": "No way!"
}

{
  "id": "p04_no_way_worker_v2_visual_only",
  "phrase_id": "p04",
  "phrase": "No way!",
  "provider": "ChatArtPro",
  "model": "Seedance 2.0 Fast",
  "submitted_at": "2026-05-24 12:19 CST",
  "diamonds_spent": 31,
  "source_url": "https://files.chatartpro.com/web-video/20260524/6a127786b081a.mp4",
  "file": "source_clips/p04_no_way/p04_no_way_chatartpro_worker_v2_visual_only.mp4",
  "status": "approved_visual_audio_stripped",
  "audio_stt": "Go away! (provider audio rejected/stripped)",
  "required_audio": "No way! controlled voiceover"
}

{
  "id": "p05_try_again_worker_v3_clear_failure",
  "phrase_id": "p05",
  "phrase": "Try again.",
  "provider": "ChatArtPro",
  "model": "Seedance 2.0 Fast",
  "submitted_at": "2026-05-25 08:20 CST",
  "diamonds_spent": 31,
  "source_url": "https://files.chatartpro.com/web-video/20260524/6a131a3e4e8d4.mp4",
  "file": "source_clips/p05_try_again/p05_try_again_chatartpro_fast_visual_v3_clear_failure.mp4",
  "status": "usable_but_needs_minor_fix",
  "visual_qa": "Failure evidence clear; Try again/rebuild action still weak."
}

{
  "id": "p05_try_again_worker_v4_failure_then_rebuild",
  "phrase_id": "p05",
  "phrase": "Try again.",
  "provider": "ChatArtPro",
  "model": "Seedance 2.0 Fast",
  "submitted_at": "2026-05-25 08:29 CST",
  "diamonds_spent": 31,
  "source_url": "https://files.chatartpro.com/web-video/20260525/6a13966c0dfbb.mp4",
  "file": "source_clips/p05_try_again/p05_try_again_chatartpro_fast_visual_v4_failure_then_rebuild.mp4",
  "status": "rejected_by_human_review_needs_8s_regeneration",
  "visual_qa": "Original agent score revised after user review: 5/10. Failure not animated; only starts from failed image.",
  "required_audio": "Try again. controlled local childlike voiceover"
}

{
  "id": "p01_watch_out_agent_retry_v3_qa",
  "verdict": "approved_restored",
  "summary": "p01 source clip restored after reset correction; approved candidate with required intro trim/mask."
}

{
  "id": "p02_hold_on_black_soot_v2_qa",
  "verdict": "not_approved_candidate",
  "summary": "Visual improved with soot-blackened faces but rocket missing after explosion; audio STT has extra Hahaha before Hold on, so cannot approve raw source."
}

{
  "id": "p02_hold_on_seedance2_timing_v3_qa",
  "verdict": "candidate_audio_timing_pass_visual_partial",
  "summary": "Seedance 2.0 candidate: STT exact Hold on at 0.00-0.82 before press; visual has rocket/button before press and soot faces after, but STOP gesture is weak and rocket missing after explosion."
}

{
  "id": "p02_hold_on_fast_topbutton_stophand_v4_qa",
  "verdict": "candidate_stt_pass_awaiting_human_visual_review",
  "summary": "STT exact Hold on only; automated visual QA unavailable due vision usage limit. Sent video/contact sheet for user review."
}

{
  "id": "p03_my_turn_chatartpro_preflight_login_blocked",
  "verdict": "blocked_not_submitted",
  "summary": "Prepared p03 My turn provider prompt; ChatArtPro I2V page loaded but showed Login and 0 diamonds, so generation was not submitted and no credits spent.",
  "file": "prompts/p03_my_turn_chatartpro_provider_prompt.txt"
}

{
  "id": "final_story_v1_gate_qa",
  "verdict": "pass",
  "summary": "Final story early gate completed after restoration; not a flat phrase chain, uses rocket-building mini-plot with visible actions per taught phrase.",
  "updated_at": "2026-05-23 10:34:25 CST"
}

{
  "id": "p03_my_turn_chatartpro_fast_v1_qa",
  "verdict": "candidate_visual_usable_audio_pass_needs_minor_review",
  "summary": "Downloaded and verified p03 MP4. STT exact My turn only; no extra words. Visual meaning clear enough for turn-taking, but first-frame ghosting and slightly realistic tool require minor/human review.",
  "updated_at": "2026-05-24 09:30 CST",
  "file": "qa/p03_my_turn_contact_sheet.jpg"
}

{
  "id": "p03_my_turn_agent_final_assembly_qa",
  "verdict": "phrase_segment_complete",
  "summary": "Role-agent QA completed. @圖片審核Agent required 1.0s intro trim; @聲音Agent approved original audio; @審核Agent approved final 3-pass assembled segment. Final STT: My turn. repeated 3 times only.",
  "updated_at": "2026-05-24 09:55 CST",
  "file": "assembled_segments/p03_my_turn/p03_my_turn_3pass_v1.mp4"
}

{
  "id": "p04_no_way_agent_preflight",
  "verdict": "pass_provider_prompt_ready",
  "summary": "@視覺Agent, @聲音Agent, @審核Agent preflight PASS. Single-paragraph ChatArtPro prompt saved; must submit via non-disruptive/background path, not visible-window download workflow.",
  "updated_at": "2026-05-24 10:08 CST",
  "file": "prompts/p04_no_way_chatartpro_provider_prompt.txt"
}

{
  "id": "p04_no_way_worker_v1_qa",
  "verdict": "rejected_visual_audio_failed",
  "summary": "v1 failed: missing large bubbles/surprised reaction; intro reference hold; STT My turn! not No way!.",
  "updated_at": "2026-05-24 12:30 CST",
  "file": "qa/p04_no_way_contact_sheet.jpg"
}

{
  "id": "p04_no_way_worker_v2_source_qa",
  "verdict": "pass_with_audio_strip",
  "summary": "v2 visual source passed after trim 1.0s; provider audio STT Go away! so stripped. Mouth/action acceptable for controlled No way! voiceover.",
  "updated_at": "2026-05-24 12:30 CST",
  "file": "qa/p04_no_way_v2_contact_sheet.jpg"
}

{
  "id": "p04_no_way_agent_final_assembly_qa",
  "verdict": "phrase_segment_complete_with_voice_quality_caveat",
  "summary": "Final 3-pass assembled segment approved: pass1 no subtitles, pass2 English No way!, pass3 English+繁中 不會吧！ STT small+VAD found No way x3. Caveat: controlled TTS uses Edge provider; human review recommended for childlike voice quality.",
  "updated_at": "2026-05-24 12:30 CST",
  "file": "assembled_segments/p04_no_way/p04_no_way_3pass_v1.mp4"
}

{
  "id": "p05_try_again_v2_human_rejection",
  "verdict": "rejected_visual_semantics",
  "summary": "User rejected v2 because the visual only showed retry/rebuild, not the prior failure; viewer could not know what was being tried again.",
  "updated_at": "2026-05-25 08:32 CST",
  "file": "qa/p05_candidate_contact_sheets/p05_try_again_chatartpro_fast_visual_v2_fallen_rocket_sheet.jpg"
}

{
  "id": "p05_try_again_v4_source_qa",
  "verdict": "pass_visual_audio_strip",
  "summary": "v4 source passed visual QA: clear failed broken/scattered rocket, sad Leo, Mia encourages, both begin rebuilding. Provider audio stripped.",
  "updated_at": "2026-05-25 08:32 CST",
  "file": "qa/p05_candidate_contact_sheets/p05_try_again_chatartpro_fast_visual_v4_failure_then_rebuild_sheet.jpg"
}

{
  "id": "p05_try_again_agent_final_assembly_qa",
  "verdict": "phrase_segment_complete",
  "summary": "Final 3-pass assembled segment approved: pass1 no subtitles, pass2 English Try again., pass3 English+繁中 再試一次。 Controlled F5-TTS B slow 0.75x STT exact pass.",
  "updated_at": "2026-05-25 08:32 CST",
  "file": "assembled_segments/p05_try_again/p05_try_again_3pass_v1.mp4"
}

{
  "id": "p05_try_again_v4_human_rejection_8s_logic_revision",
  "verdict": "rejected_by_human_review_needs_logic_and_prompt_revision",
  "score": "5/10",
  "summary": "User rejected p05 because the opening failure has no animation; it starts already failed, so the cause is not intuitive. Regenerate as 8-second visual-only clip with animated failure first.",
  "updated_at": "2026-05-25 09:58 CST",
  "user_feedback": "p05的影片不適合的原因是開頭的失敗沒有動畫，只有開頭就是失敗的畫面，這樣還是不夠直覺，可能是影片秒數不夠，改成生成8秒的影片",
  "responsible_agents": [
    "@審核Agent",
    "@視覺Agent",
    "@Provider Execution Agent",
    "@組裝Agent"
  ],
  "logic_revision": "p05 Try again must animate the failure on screen before retry: upright/wobbly rocket being assembled -> visible collapse/fall-apart -> sad reaction -> encouragement -> retry/rebuild. Use 8s visual-only source clip instead of 5s so the failure animation is intuitive.",
  "prompt_revision_file": "prompts/p05_try_again_chatartpro_visual_only_v5_8s_failure_animation.txt",
  "file": "qa/p05_try_again_human_rejection_v4_8s_logic_revision.md"
}